Slug
Sanding How-To
Article by James
'Agg' Rolfe
As is traditional, let me start
off with a standard disclaimer. Slug sanding is getting into
the "extreme overclocking" range of activities. Be
aware that there is a chance of destroying your CPU by doing
this. I provide this article for information and entertainment
only - if you choose to sand your own CPU slugs, you do so AT YOUR OWN RISK. I can afford to lose a CPU or two in
the course of experimentation and I accept that risk - that may
not be true for you. Having said that, I have sanded 6 CPU's
to full copper (I'll explain that later) and they all work fine
still. However, READ
THE ENTIRE ARTICLE BEFORE PROCEEDING.
I have deliberately not included a "What you need"
section to force you to read the whole thing first. Oh, and you
are DEFINITELY voiding your warranty.
Right, that's kept the lawyers
happy. Now - what the hell is slug sanding anyway? If you follow
the overclocking newsgroup (alt.comp.hardware.overclocking)
or read hardware sites you will have encountered the term at
some point. It's nothing too mystical, basically you sand the
top of the CPU's casing so that it's nice and flat, so you get
better thermal transfer to the heatsink. This makes your CPU's
run cooler, and may help you achieve stability at higher speeds.
You will notice the most improvement on CPU's that have very
warped slugs - usually the corners are higher than the centre,
so they "push" the core of the CPU, the bit that gets
the hottest and needs the most cooling, away from the heatsink.
Thermal paste can fill the gap, but having a flat slug is better
- and a flat slug with paste on it is best of all. You may also
want to consider sanding your heatsink - but we'll not be covering
that today..
We'll only be looking at PPGA
Celerons today. You can sand the Slot1 ones too, but apparently
sanding PentiumII's and III's is a bad idea.. we don't have any
here, so I'm not sure why that is. Anyway.. here's what the slug
looks like before sanding:
The slug is the raised bit of
silvery stuff in the middle. There's usually a strange little
logo right in the centre of it. This logo also appears on the
other side of the chip.. anyone know what it is? :) (UPDATE:
It's a 2D barcode which contains all the info on the chip, batch
number, S-code etc)
An important thing to keep in
mind when sanding your slug is that you don't want to make it
any worse than it currently is. So you need to have a very flat
surface for sanding on - glass is ideal. I use a sheet of glass
with sandpaper taped to the top of it, like so:
The big pile of Gatorade bottles
is helpful but not required. :) Some people say you have to use
Silicon Carbide sandpaper but when I asked for that at the local
hardware store all I got was blank looks. The generic dark-grey
wet/dry stuff worked fine for me (in the photos it looks brown
because of the copper from the CPU's - when you buy it, it's
all the same colour as the corners). I start with grade 280,
then change to 600 to get it really flat, then to 1200 to polish
to a nice shiny finish. You will still have scratches on the
surface - you're never going to get to a true "mirror"
finish, but you should be able to see your face reflected in
it - it should be nice and shiny, and FLAT, by the time you finish.
Keep in mind that you are scraping
little tiny peices of METAL off the cpu when you do this. So
don't do it ANYWHERE NEAR your PC or anything else that might
be damaged by tiny conductive particles. Do it somewhere where
you can properly clean up afterwards, vacuum the whole area etc.
Before you start, you need to
protect the CPU. You need to make sure you don't leave metal
particles that could short out the pins when you put it back
in the socket. The best way to avoid this is to never get them
near the pins in the first place. Also, you need to protect it
against static and against water if you're going to be wetsanding.
You also want to be careful not to bend the pins - this is usually
not catastrophic, but it's a pain in the neck to straighten them
out properly if you bend them.
The best way to protect against
all these things is to seal the CPU inside a static-proof bag
while leaving the slug exposed. To do this, drop the CPU into
the corner of an antistatic bag. Cut the bag away so you have
a little pocket of bag around the chip. Leave about 1.5cm around
it - it's better to leave too much than too little. Fold the
open sides around and tape them on the bottom (the PIN side).
So you now have the CPU completely sealed in a little antistatic
pocket:
|
|
|
top (slug side) |
bottom (pin side) |
Now, to expose the slug so you
can sand it. Cut around the slug with a stanley knife or similar
- you want to actually expose a fair bit of the area around the
slug - I usually leave about a 5mm gap. This is so you can stick
the sides of the hole to the chip itself with sticky tape, to
maintain the seal, while still exposing the slug. See the next
pictures:
|
|
|
cut open, before taping |
taped |
Now! The CPU is in a mostly static-proof
package, which is also waterproof and metal-shavings-proof. Also,
there should now be a fair bit of stickytape and folded static
bag protecting the pins on the bottom from your clumsy fingers
during sanding. Now we're ready to sand. Allow yourself some
time for this - you don't want to be rushing it. Say half an
hour or so to make sure you do it properly.
Moisten the roughest sandpaper
(the lowest grade number, in my case 280). You can dry-sand if
you like, but I find wetsanding to be better because it keeps
the chip cooler, it makes it a little easier on the arm and it
keeps the metal dust and shavings together. I usually do the
280 wet and then the 600 wet, then use the 1200 dry to finish
off. I keep a glass of water nearby so I can dip my fingers into
it and sprinkle water onto the sandpaper from them. Smooth the
drops around on the paper - you don't want to be running your
chip through huge puddles of water, you just want very moist
sandpaper.
Hold the cpu slug-down (derr)
with your thumb and middle finger each on a side. Press down
on the middle of the bottom of the CPU with your index finger
(between the pins):
I might just take a moment to
remind you that you are doing this at your own risk. If you think
you're going to be really pissed off (to the point of, say, suing
webmasters) if you wreck your chip in the next 20 minutes, stop
now. Be happy with whatever speed you're currently stable at.
Otherwise..
Remember to keep the slug flat
against the sandpaper. Some people say you should do alternating
circles, some people say do figure-8's, some people say only
do straight lines. What I normally do is do 20 circles, then
rotate the cpu 90 degrees, 20 more, rotate 90, 20 more, etc etc
etc. I figure that way if there's any bias in the way I'm sanding
it should even out over the course of the process. What you really
want to avoid is letting the cpu tilt while you sand, so that
you end up rounding the corners off. Check it regularly with
a flat surface such as the heatsink, or better yet a razor blade
edge or steel ruler or similar. I use a little 6-inch steel ruler
I bought from the hardware shop for about $6.00.
Now, the primary goal here is
to get the slug FLAT. You may reach a flat slug in no time at
all. Mine were all not very warped, so what I was really trying
to do was get as much of the material off the top of the slug
as possible, while keeping it flat. Underneath the silvery stuff
there is coppery stuff. Very scientific, I know, but nobody has
actually confirmed what the metals we're dealing with here are,
as far as I know. But I'll call the coppery stuff copper because
it probably is. Sometimes you will get to a completely flat CPU
and still have lots of silver on the slug. Sometimes you will
have a pattern of part-copper, part-silver. I always sand to
full copper, ie, the whole slug is coppery coloured, because
I want to get the best thermal transfer I can. Now, warning time:
if you sand too far down onto the slug, you will kill your cpu.
Under the slug is the silicon bed that is the real heart of the
chip. It's actually on the back of the slug. If you expose that
your chip is screwed. So be careful how far down you go. Also,
even if you don't go all the way through to the silicon, you
may weaken the slug to the point where it collapses when you
mount a heatsink on it. This is also a chip-killer. So be careful!
|
|
|
copper showing on all 4 sides |
almost finished |
Is your arm tired yet? :) You
may find your stickytape and static bag are being sanded away
a bit. This is not that unusual but try not to break the seal
- and definitely don't sand away much of the ceramic package
(the dark outer bit that the pins are sticking out of).
When you have a lovely polished
flat surface, carefully blow or vacuum away all the dust and
metal shavings and cut the tape and staticbag away from the cpu.
It's easiest if you cut along the sides of the cpu casing and
pull the bag apart that way. Vacuum and clean the cpu properly
with a tissue, clean your hands thoroughly and clean up your
work area. You may want to rinse the sandpaper off so you can
use it again - I use wet/dry sandpaper so I just take the whole
glass sheet into the shower and rub it almost clean. Now stand
back and admire your masterpeice!

mirror mirror on the slug
Now - was it all worth it? In
my experience yes - every one of the 6 C366's I've sanded to
full copper have shown a drop in temperature - usually 1 or 2
degrees C. This can be all the difference between stability and
crashes when you're on the edge. It makes a much more marked
difference if you're looking into active cooling - my 2 best
C366's would lock up just after loading W98 at 616MHz with a
40W peltier on them - they run well enough to install Sandra
and run a few benchmarks now. They'll even let me play about
10 minutes of Sports Car GT! Click here for the full Peltier experiment story.
So don't expect miracles - but
do expect a difference. If you're right on the edge and you think
heat is the problem, sanding might pay off. Of course, as I keep
saying, you are taking something of a risk with the CPU - not
a big risk in my experience, but as with all things when overclocking
- nothing's guaranteed. :)
Read our reader's
comments on this article!
Want
to comment on this article?
Click here to discuss it in the forums! |