Well, I've had a fun couple of weekends testing all the Socket-370 heatsink/fan combinations I could lay my hands on! I tested them in one of our Celeron 366 @ 550MHz testbeds, each for 20 minutes of Unreal flyby with the SETI cmd-line client running in the background. This locked the CPU at 100% utilization, and was long enough to indicate how well the cooler was getting the heat off the CPU. We left the machine with the cover off for 10 minutes between tests, to allow it to cool down.
All up, 7 different units were put through their paces, firstly with the stock thermal pads and then with thermal paste applied and the pad removed. We used 2 different chips with each unit - one normal 2.0 chip and a 2.2v chip sanded to full copper. So in total there's 26 temperature readings. This took a very long time. :) Let it not be said we do things half-heartedly at Overclockers Australia!
Are all coolers created equal? Is it really worth paying extra? Read on to find out..
Firstly, an introduction to the units included in the test. A notable absence is the Alpha socket-370 cooler. This is not included because [a] they're not easily available in Australia (yet - I'm working on it :) ) [b] the general concensus from the overclocking community seems to be that the Socket370's are not on par with their Slot-1 counterparts - the new GlobalWins are as good if not better, and [c] we don't have one yet. :)
First up, the Intel Retail Heatsink/Fan:
Actually, there seem to be at least 2 different units included with the retail Celeron PPGA 366A's. See the photos below.
The "old" type came with the first batch of 366's we got, week 14's. The "new" type came with some week 15's and 17's we got a bit later. We don't know if there's actually a time correlation between them, but we're going to call them "old" and "new" to differentiate them. Here's a quick summary of differences we spotted:
As these are obviously very different units we thought we'd see how they compare performance-wise. Unfortunately neither provide the capability to monitor the fan's RPM so we couldn't see if they differ there. Another problem with the retail units is that the cable is very short. It's long enough to get to the nearest fan connector on the Aopen AX6BC-Pro, but not long enough to get to the other one. This may be a problem as some people don't like using the "smart" connectors as wayward software can sometimes turn the fan off. If you have a peltier on your system this can be catastrophic.. (but then again - if you're using a peltier with the retail heatsink/fan you deserve everything you get :) )
Globalwin CPM25603-16:
This unit has formed the backbone of our overclocked C366 business. A solid performer, it has been recently superceded by the CPM25603-32 (which used to be called the CPM25603-12 but was renamed). It uses the Superred CHA6012DB-A fan, which moves 20cfm.
Globalwin CPM25603-32:
This unit sports the same 25mm-high heatsink as the -16 unit, but boasts a newer, more powerful fan (a YS-Tech FD1260257B-2A 2.16W unit pushing 26cfm). Although it spins slower, the new fan actually pumps more air (and is noisier).
You can see the differences below. The -32's fan has much more aggressively angled blades.
All original content copyright James Rolfe.
All rights reserved. No reproduction allowed without written permission.
Interested in advertising on OCAU? Contact us for info.
Fortune Cookie:
One day this guy is finally fed up with his middle-class existence and
decides to do something about it. He calls up his best friend, who is a
mathematical genius. "Look," he says, "do you suppose you could find some
way mathematically of guaranteeing winning at the race track? We could
make a lot of money and retire and enjoy life." The mathematician thinks
this over a bit and walks away mumbling to himself.
A week later his friend drops by to ask the genius if he's had any
success. The genius, looking a little bleary-eyed, replies, "Well, yes,
actually I do have an idea, and I'm reasonably sure that it will work, but
there a number of details to be figured out.
After the second week the mathematician appears at his friend's house,
looking quite a bit rumpled, and announces, "I think I've got it! I still have
some of the theory to work out, but now I'm certain that I'm on the right
track."
At the end of the third week the mathematician wakes his friend by
pounding on his door at three in the morning. He has dark circles under his
eyes. His hair hasn't been combed for many days. He appears to be wearing
the same clothes as the last time. He has several pencils sticking out from
behind his ears and an almost maniacal expression on his face. "WE CAN DO
IT! WE CAN DO IT!!" he shrieks. "I have discovered the perfect solution!!
And it's so EASY! First, we assume that horses are perfect spheres in simple
harmonic motion..."
This page /article.php?id=312248 was built in 0.483839 seconds on Sunday, November 22 2009 at
11:52:10.
